Last updated November 5, 2026 by Matthew McMahon.
The short answer: to buy an off-market home in Chicago, look for homes that were already listed, expired or were canceled, and never sold, then ask the owner’s last listing agent whether the owner would look at an offer from a buyer who is pre-approved and will live there. Net Gain Realty runs that search for its buyer clients as part of the flat $7,500 buyer fee: every unsold listing in the buyer’s area from the last 24 months, checked against Cook County records, then a short question to each owner the buyer picks.
This page describes the method, so you can judge it, and so you know exactly what Net Gain Realty does when it runs it for you.
Why Unsold Listings Make a Good Off-Market List
An owner who listed a home and then pulled it without selling has wanted to sell at least once. Listings end without a sale for different reasons, and the MLS does not record why.
That makes the group better than a random mailing list of owners:
| Source | Has the owner ever wanted to sell? | Can you reach someone who knows the owner? |
|---|---|---|
| Random owner mailing | Unknown | No |
| Expired or canceled listing, never sold | Yes, at least once | Yes, the last listing agent |
| Active listing | Yes, right now | Yes, but every other buyer can too |
How Net Gain Realty Runs the Search
- Criteria and pre-approval first. Property type, price ceiling, neighborhoods, and whether busy streets are out. A pre-approval letter is required before anyone is contacted.
- Every unsold listing in your area. Net Gain Realty searches the MLS for listings that expired or were canceled in the last 24 months, across every property type, so an owner who relisted a two-flat as a single-family home still appears.
- Records check. Each address is checked against Cook County Assessor sales, Cook County Clerk deed recordings and current MLS status. Anything that sold off-market, came back on the market or went under contract is removed before you see it.
- You pick. You mark each address Yes, Maybe or No. Nobody is contacted without your Yes.
- One short question to the last listing agent. The broker asks whether the owner would be opposed to looking at an offer from a pre-approved buyer who will live in the home. No price and no pressure in the first message.
- A written offer after any yes. Your pre-approval is attached, so the owner is looking at a contract, not a phone call.
- Letters to owners last. For addresses where the agent never answers, a letter to the owner can follow.
Net Gain Realty’s most recent client (November 2026): the first round of outreach
For Net Gain Realty’s most recent off-market buyer client, an owner-occupant looking for a 2-to-4 unit building on Chicago’s North Side, the first round of outreach went out in November 2026. Listing agents for 9 of 15 unsold buildings replied within about a day. Listing agents relayed that 2 owners would look at an offer, and written offers were prepared for both. Four said the owner would not sell, and the other 3 replies were neither a yes nor a no. No purchase from that search had closed as of November 5, 2026, so treat this as a response rate, not a result.
Who This Fits, and Who It Does Not
The search fits pre-approved buyers who will live in the home:
- 2-to-4 unit buildings where you live in one unit and rent the others. A lender may finance these as owner-occupied if you live in one unit.
- Single-family homes in the neighborhoods you choose.
- Condos and townhouses, where association rules, rental caps and special assessments get checked before an offer.
It does not fit a buyer who is not pre-approved, who needs weeks to decide, or who expects a discount for being off-market.
What It Does Not Promise
In the one search above, listing agents relayed that 4 owners would not sell and 2 would look at an offer. Off-market does not mean below market: the owner still sets the price, and the buyer still decides whether the price makes sense using sold comparables. What the method changes is how many buyers the owner is comparing you against, which on an off-market home may be no one else.
What It Costs
The off-market search is part of the Net Gain Realty flat-fee buyer service: $7,500 total, with $595 at signing credited toward it and the $6,905 balance at closing, requested from the seller on every offer, and the seller can say no. There is no separate fee for the search, the outreach or the offers. How a flat buyer fee changes what your offer asks of the seller is explained on its own page.
Method and figures as of November 5, 2026. The response rate above is from one search for one buyer and is not a prediction for any other search. Fees in any transaction are set by its written agreements.
Questions sellers ask
What does off-market mean when you are buying a home in Chicago?
An off-market home is one the owner is not currently offering for sale on the MLS. One useful group for a buyer is homes that were listed, expired or were canceled, and never sold. Those owners already wanted to sell once. Net Gain Realty builds a buyer's off-market list from exactly that group, then checks each address against Cook County sale and deed records so homes that quietly sold are removed.
How does Net Gain Realty find off-market homes for buyers?
Net Gain Realty pulls every listing in the buyer's area that expired or was canceled in the last 24 months, removes anything that sold, relisted or went under contract according to the MLS and Cook County records, and has the buyer mark each remaining address Yes, Maybe or No. For each Yes, the broker asks the owner's last listing agent whether the owner would be opposed to looking at an offer from a pre-approved buyer who will live in the home. When the answer is yes, a written offer follows.
Who is the off-market search for?
Net Gain Realty runs the off-market search for buyers who are pre-approved, have signed a buyer representation agreement, and will live in the home: a 2-to-4 unit building with the buyer in one unit, a single-family house, a condo or a townhouse. The search is not built for buyers who are still deciding whether to buy.
What does the off-market search cost?
Nothing beyond the Net Gain Realty buyer fee, which is a flat $7,500: a $595 initial fee credited toward the total when you sign, and the $6,905 balance at closing, which every offer requests from the seller. The off-market search, the listing-agent outreach and the offers are part of the same flat fee. Never a percentage, at any price point.
Does off-market mean I get a lower price?
No. Off-market means fewer competing buyers in the conversation, not a discount. The owner still decides the price. What the search changes is that the buyer may be the only offer the owner is looking at, instead of one of several on a listed home.
What happens if two Net Gain Realty buyers want the same off-market home?
Net Gain Realty works first come, first served. Net Gain Realty contacts an owner on behalf of the buyer who marked that address Yes in writing first, and does not put two of its own buyers against each other on one off-market property. A second buyer who wants the same address is told it is already in progress for another client.
Is contacting the owner of an off-market home legal in Illinois?
Yes. A licensed Illinois broker can ask an owner, or the owner's former listing agent, whether the owner would consider an offer. Net Gain Realty contacts the last listing agent first, keeps the question to a few lines, and takes no for an answer. Net Gain Realty is a licensed Illinois brokerage, license #481.014232.
Ready to write a stronger offer?
$7,500 flat. Your offer never carries a percentage.
Every offer written and negotiated personally by a licensed broker. A flat fee never grows against your budget.