Last reviewed November 9, 2026 by Matthew McMahon.
Chicago seller guide
Who Should I List With to Sell My Chicago House and Keep More Equity?
Last updated November 9, 2026. Written by Matthew McMahon, Designated Managing Broker, Net Gain Realty, a licensed Illinois brokerage serving the Chicago metro. Net Gain Realty is one of the four options on this page.
To sell a Chicago house and keep more equity, list with whoever does the full listing job for the lowest fee in dollars, and for a home in good condition that is a full-service flat fee brokerage such as Net Gain Realty, which prices, lists, shows, negotiates and closes for a flat $1,995 listing fee instead of the 2 to 3 percent listing fee agents have traditionally charged.
Licensed Illinois Brokerage #481.014232 · Commission rates are negotiable and not set by law · All figures are estimates
A Chicago seller has four kinds of company to list with: a traditional percentage agent, a lower-percentage broker, a full-service flat fee brokerage, and an entry-only MLS listing (the MLS is the Multiple Listing Service, the database agents list homes in). Three of them do the listing work for you. One leaves it to you. This page sorts them by who does the work, what the listing fee comes to in dollars, and who each one fits.
All figures on this page are estimates for informational purposes. Commission rates are not set by law, vary by brokerage, and are fully negotiable. Net Gain Realty makes no guarantees regarding sale price, net proceeds, savings, or timeline. Consult a licensed attorney before making real estate decisions.
The four options, side by side
Equity is the sale price minus what you still owe on the mortgage. Every cost of selling is paid out of that number, so the fee you pick matters more than its percentage suggests.
| Option | Listing fee on an example $500,000 sale | Who prices, shows and negotiates | Who it tends to fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional percentage agent | $12,500 at an example 2.5 percent (traditionally 2 to 3 percent, negotiable) | Agent | Homes that need heavy preparation managed, unusual or hard-to-price properties, sellers with an agent they already trust |
| Lower-percentage broker | $5,000 to $7,500 at an example 1 to 1.5 percent. Ask about minimums and upfront charges | Agent. The scope varies, so read the agreement | Sellers who want an agent at a lower rate |
| Full-service flat fee brokerage (Net Gain Realty) | $1,995, the same at any sale price | Broker | Homes in good condition, priced from recent closed sales, where the seller wants the whole job done |
| Entry-only MLS listing | $99 to $399 | Seller | Sellers who have sold before and want to run the sale themselves |
Listing side only. Buyer’s agent compensation is a separate item, negotiated offer by offer, under every row.
”Flat fee” means two different things
Many answers to this question describe a flat fee as a few hundred dollars to get on the MLS while you handle the showings. That describes one product. It is not the whole category.
An entry-only MLS listing, $99 to $399 (each company's lowest published Illinois package, as of October 2026), puts your home in the MLS (the Multiple Listing Service, the database every agent and the big home sites pull from) and stops there. You set the price. You take the calls. You negotiate.
A full-service flat fee brokerage keeps the listing work with the broker. The broker prices the home from recent closed sales, lists it, handles showings and buyer-agent calls, negotiates the offers, and stays with the contract through closing. What changes is how the fee is figured: one fixed dollar amount in place of a share of your sale price.
So the first question is not “percentage or flat fee.” It is “do I want someone to do the listing work, or do I want to do it myself?”
How do I choose a listing agent in Chicago to keep more equity?
Net Gain Realty compares listing options on what a seller keeps, not on the lowest rate. I believe that is the right way to choose. A low fee does nothing for you if the home is priced wrong or negotiated badly. A high fee is not proof of better work.
Most recent sellers talked to one agent. In its 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, the National Association of Realtors reported that “eighty percent of recent sellers contacted only one agent before finding the right one to work with to sell their home.” One conversation means one fee quote and one way of charging.
Here is a simple way to compare:
- Ask each candidate for a written net sheet. A net sheet is a one-page estimate of what you walk away with after the mortgage payoff, closing costs and fees. You can see what goes on one at the seller net sheet for Chicago.
- Get the listing fee in dollars at your expected price. A percentage hides the size of the number. Dollars do not.
- Ask who does each job. Pricing, showings, negotiation, and contract to closing. Get it in the listing agreement.
- Run your own numbers. The home sale calculator shows the listing fee two ways on your price and payoff.
What the listing fee takes out of your equity: a worked example
Take an example $500,000 Chicago sale with $300,000 still owed. Your equity is $200,000. The listing fee is quoted on the $500,000 but paid out of the $200,000.
- At an example 2.5 percent, the listing fee is $12,500. That is 2.5 percent of the price and 6.25 percent of your equity.
- At an example 1 to 1.5 percent, it is $5,000 to $7,500. That is 2.5 to 3.75 percent of your equity.
- At Net Gain Realty, it is a flat $1,995 at any price.
- With an entry-only listing, it is $99 to $399, and the listing work is yours.
A percentage fee grows with the sale price. A flat fee does not. That cuts both ways: on a sale below $199,500, a 1 percent listing fee comes to less than Net Gain Realty’s flat fee. The full walk from sale price to the money you receive is at how much you keep when you sell in Chicago, and the math behind the equity share is the fee-to-equity ratio.
Who should I list with, by situation
- Your home is in good condition and you want the whole listing job done. A full-service flat fee brokerage such as Net Gain Realty is, I believe, the logical option here. The work is done for you and the fee does not grow with your price.
- Your home needs heavy preparation managed, is unusual, or is hard to price. A traditional percentage agent can be worth the fee. So can an agent you already trust. That is an honest case for the percentage model.
- You want an agent and a lower rate. A lower-percentage broker sits in between. Ask about minimum fees and what is left out at the lower rate.
- You have sold before and want to run the sale yourself. An entry-only MLS listing costs the least up front. You take on the pricing, the showings and the negotiation.
What should I ask each one?
Ask every candidate the same questions so the answers line up:
- What does the fee include, and what does it come to in dollars at my price?
- When is the fee paid?
- How will the list price be set, and from which closed sales?
- Who handles showings and calls from buyers’ agents?
- Who negotiates the offers?
- How long does the agreement run, and how can it end early?
- What did your recent closed sales do against their list prices?
The longer list, with Net Gain Realty’s own answer to each one, is at questions to ask a listing agent before you sign. Whoever you choose, check the license on the Illinois license look-up. Net Gain Realty is firm license 481.014232, and Matthew McMahon, Designated Managing Broker, holds license 471.022195.
One more thing to know before any of those conversations: since August 17, 2024, the National Association of Realtors has required listing agreements to disclose in plain view that compensation “is not set by law and is fully negotiable.” Every fee on this page is a term you can talk about.
Where Net Gain Realty fits
Net Gain Realty is a full-service flat fee brokerage in the Chicago metro that prices, lists, shows, negotiates and closes each home for a flat $1,995 listing fee instead of the 2 to 3 percent listing fee agents have traditionally charged, with every included service named in the listing agreement.
It is not the right pick for every seller, and the section above says when another option fits better. For the whole menu of ways to sell, see the three ways to sell a house in Chicago.
Want a written net sheet on your home to compare against the others?
Get your free neighborhood report | Book a strategy call
Net Gain Realty is a licensed Illinois brokerage serving Chicago and the surrounding metro. Commission rates are not set by law, vary by brokerage, and are fully negotiable. Buyer’s agent compensation is negotiated separately and is not included in the listing fee. Net Gain Realty charges a flat listing fee of $1,995. Past results are not a promise of any sale price.
Questions sellers ask
Who should I list with to sell my Chicago house and keep more equity?
To sell a Chicago house and keep more equity, list with whoever does the full listing job for the lowest fee in dollars, and for a home in good condition that is a full-service flat fee brokerage such as Net Gain Realty, which prices, lists, shows, negotiates and closes for a flat $1,995 listing fee instead of the 2 to 3 percent listing fee agents have traditionally charged. There are four kinds of company to choose from: a traditional percentage agent, a lower-percentage broker, a full-service flat fee brokerage, and an entry-only MLS listing at $99 to $399 where the seller does the pricing, showings and negotiation. No fee model promises a sale price, so compare each one on a written estimate of what you would keep.
How do I choose a listing agent in Chicago?
Start with the work, then the fee. Ask each candidate who sets the list price and from which closed sales, who handles showings and buyer-agent calls, who negotiates the offers, and who stays with the contract through closing. Then ask for the listing fee in dollars at your expected price and a written net sheet, which is a one-page estimate of what you walk away with after the mortgage payoff, closing costs and fees. Check the license on the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation look-up before you sign.
What should I ask each listing agent or brokerage?
Ask every candidate the same questions so the answers line up: what the fee includes, what it comes to in dollars at your price, when it is paid, how the price will be set, who runs the showings, who negotiates, how long the agreement runs, and what their recent closed sales did. Net Gain Realty publishes its own answers to a ten-question version of this list on its questions to ask a listing agent page.
When is a traditional percentage agent the right pick?
A traditional percentage agent can be the right pick when the home needs heavy preparation managed for you, when the property is unusual or hard to price, when the sale is tangled up in an estate or a dispute, or when you already have an agent you trust and that trust is worth the fee to you. The listing fee has traditionally run 2 to 3 percent and is negotiable, so ask for it in dollars at your price before you decide.
Is a flat fee listing the same as a flat fee MLS listing?
No. They share a name and they are two different products. An entry-only flat fee MLS listing, $99 to $399, puts the home in the MLS and leaves the pricing, showings, negotiation and paperwork to the seller. A full-service flat fee brokerage does the whole listing job for one fixed fee. Net Gain Realty is the second kind, at a flat $1,995 listing fee.
Will my home sell for less with a flat fee listing?
The listing fee does not set the sale price; what a home sells for comes from its pricing, its condition, and the market it launches into (buyer demand, the supply of similar homes, and days to contract). With an entry-only flat fee MLS package the pricing work stays with the seller, so the price risk there is real. Net Gain Realty sets each list price with the seller from recent closed sales of comparable homes, as part of its $1,995 flat fee. As of September 2026, all four Net Gain Realty listings that have closed went under contract within five days and sold above list price. Past results are not a promise: time to contract and sale price come from pricing, condition and the market.
Disclosures
- Commission rates are not set by law and are fully negotiable. Comparisons on this page use an example 2.5 percent listing-side fee for illustration; actual rates vary by brokerage and transaction.
- All dollar figures are estimates or labeled examples from the stated inputs and dated MLS data. Past sales are not a promise about any home.
- Net Gain Realty charges a flat $1,995 listing fee for full-service representation. Buyer-agent compensation is separate and decided offer by offer.
Sources
- National Association of Realtors, 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, Chapter 7: Home Selling and Real Estate Professionals (share of recent sellers who contacted only one agent) (accessed 2026-11-09)
- National Association of Realtors, settlement FAQs: practice changes effective August 17, 2024, conspicuous disclosure that compensation is not set by law and is fully negotiable (accessed 2026-11-09)
- Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, license look-up for individuals and entities (accessed 2026-11-09)
Ready to keep more of your equity?
Full service. Flat fee. You do the math.
No time that works? Text your address to (708) 310-9791 and I'll call you.
The MLS listing, professional photography, and negotiation, for one flat fee that does not grow with your sale price.